S-Corp Highly Compensated Employee Status: 2027 Rules

S-Corp Highly Compensated Employee Status: 2027 Rules





Contact Us

If you own more than 5% of your S-corporation, you are a highly compensated employee for 401(k) testing purposes, full stop, no matter what salary you pay yourself. Ownership alone decides it under IRC Section 414(q), separate from the dollar threshold most owners assume is the only test. For 2027, the IRS also raised that alternate compensation threshold to $170,000 — though because the test looks at prior-year pay, the new figure governs your 2027 wages when setting HCE status for 2028; your 2027 status rides on whether your 2026 pay topped $160,000. Here is what the classification actually triggers inside your plan, and how to design around it before it costs you a refund check you didn’t want.

Two Ways to Trigger Highly Compensated Employee Status

The IRS defines an HCE two separate ways, and a plan only needs one of them to fire. The first is pure ownership. Anyone who owned more than 5% of the business at any point during the current year or the prior year is an HCE, regardless of how much compensation that person earned or received. The second is a compensation test. Anyone whose pay from the business in the preceding year exceeded an indexed dollar threshold is also an HCE, and the employer can additionally limit that group to the top 20% of earners if it elects to. Notice 2026-66, the IRS’s 2027 cost-of-living update, raised that compensation threshold from $160,000 to $170,000. Because the test always looks backward, each year’s threshold attaches to the pay earned in that year: the new $170,000 figure applies to 2027 compensation when determining who is an HCE for the 2028 plan year, while HCE status for 2027 is settled by whether 2026 W-2 wages exceeded $160,000, the threshold in effect for 2026.

Why S-Corp Owners Almost Always Qualify

Most S-corp owners hold a majority or near-majority stake, which means the ownership prong decides their status before the compensation number is even relevant. Setting a lower salary does not get you out of this. A shareholder taking $50,000 in reasonable compensation specifically to limit payroll tax exposure is still an HCE if they own more than 5% of the stock — the two issues are unrelated. One is a question of how you set a defensible reasonable salary; the other is a fixed classification that ownership alone decides. The two decisions get made at the same time, on the same W-2, but they don’t move each other.

What HCE Status Actually Costs You: The ADP Test

A 401(k) plan that isn’t a safe harbor design has to pass the actual deferral percentage, or ADP, test every year. The test averages the deferral rate of every HCE and compares it to the average for everyone else. The spread allowed is narrow. If the non-HCE average is 2% or less, the HCE average can run up to twice that. Between 2% and 8%, the HCE average can exceed the non-HCE average by up to 2 percentage points. Above 8%, the HCE average is capped at 1.25 times the non-HCE average. An S-corp with one or two owner-employees deferring close to the $25,500 2027 limit and a handful of staff deferring little or nothing almost never clears this test on its own. Failing it means money comes back out. Excess contributions attributed to the HCEs get refunded, and that refund is taxable income in the year it’s distributed — often after the owner already filed, assuming the deduction was permanent.

The Safe Harbor Fix

A safe harbor 401(k) sidesteps ADP testing entirely by requiring the employer to contribute on behalf of every eligible non-HCE, whether or not that employee defers anything. There are two standard formulas. A 3% nonelective contribution goes to every eligible non-HCE regardless of their own deferral. A basic match instead pays 100% of each non-HCE’s deferral up to 3% of pay, plus 50% of the next 2%. Both are mandatory, both must vest immediately, and both let the owner defer up to the full 2027 limit without the plan’s numbers depending on what the rest of the staff decides to do. If your current plan isn’t safe harbor and this is the first year the math doesn’t work, a 3% nonelective contribution can still be added mid-year — the SECURE Act eliminated the participant notice requirement for nonelective safe harbor contributions — so long as the amendment is adopted more than 30 days before the plan year ends, roughly December 1 for a calendar-year plan. Miss that window and the plan can still be amended up to the end of the following plan year, but the required contribution rises to 4% — either way, not a conversation to start in January. For owners who have already maxed out a 401(k) and want more sheltered savings on top of it, a SECURE 2.0-compliant plan design and the range of retirement plan options available to S-corps are both worth a second look before year-end.

The 2027 Numbers to Build Around

Notice 2026-66 sets the full package of 2027 figures together, and they all interact. The elective deferral limit rises to $25,500, with an $8,500 catch-up at age 50 and an $11,750 “super” catch-up for ages 60 through 63. The overall Section 415(c) ceiling on combined employee and employer contributions rises to $75,000, and the compensation that can be counted toward any employer contribution formula is capped at $375,000. The highly compensated employee compensation threshold, as covered above, moves to $170,000. A related number worth tracking separately is the key employee threshold for top-heavy testing under Section 416(i), which rises to $245,000 — a different test, with different consequences, that mostly matters once a plan has been running a few years without new employees joining.

None of this is a reason to avoid a 401(k) — the deferral capacity is still one of the better tax moves available to an S-corp owner. It’s a reason to know, before the plan year closes, whether your plan’s design matches your ownership structure and your payroll. If you want a second set of eyes on whether a safe harbor amendment, a different contribution formula, or a different retirement vehicle entirely fits your S-corp better for 2027, contact us and we’ll walk through the numbers with you.

Categories: tax